EDITOR’S NOTE: The print edition of this article, published on Oct. 29, 2026, incorrectly included a photo of Selma City Councilmember Santiago Oceguera in this article as former City Manager Fernando Santillan. Beyond his role as a current council member, Oceguera has no connections to the lawsuits between Fernando Santillan and the city of Selma.
SELMA – The Fresno County Superior Court has granted a special motion to strike a civil complaint made by the city of Selma against its former city manager.
Superior Court Judge Steven Crass issued a ruling on Sept. 21 granting the special motion — also known as an anti-SLAPP motion — and striking the complaint for declaratory relief in the city’s lawsuit against Fernando Santillan. The order dismisses the city’s case against Santillan, which contained a single cause of action, while also allowing Santillan’s separate case against the city to continue.
The final judgment, which the city of Selma intends to appeal, was entered by the court Oct. 16.
In a statement sent to the Mid Valley Times, Selma City Attorney Neal Costanzo said the city will request the appeals court hear the case on a “very expedited basis” and “act quickly to reverse this very misguided, invalid order and the ensuing judgment.”
“The city looks forward to holding the former city manager accountable for his brazen violations of conflict-of-interest laws that resulted in a loss of hundreds of thousands of taxpayer dollars,” Costanzo said. “We are disappointed in the Superior Court’s indifference toward Santillan’s abuse of the public’s trust and we are confident the Court of Appeal will not allow this grave injustice to stand.”
Costanzo filed a notice of appeal on Oct. 23 and sent Santillan’s attorney, Charles Hamamjian, a letter requesting they agree to a stay — or a pause — in all proceedings in Santillan’s case against the city until the appeal is heard.
Hamamjian told the Mid Valley Times that Santillan’s legal counsel agreed with the judgment and is confident it will be upheld on appeal.
“We look forward to pursuing Mr. Santillan’s claims against the city in the other pending matter,” Hamamjian said.
Further, Santillan’s team has no plans to agree to a stay in that case.
Without this agreement, Costanzo’s letter said the city would file a petition for a writ of supersedeas with the appeals court that would mandate a stay in the enforcement of the judgment being appealed. Selma will also request a temporary, immediate stay in the proceedings while awaiting the court’s decision on the writ of supersedeas, the letter said.
Civil cases
Santillan filed his lawsuit against the city of Selma on Oct. 8, 2025, four months after the Selma City Council voted 4-1 to terminate his employment. The lawsuit named both the city of Selma and Selma Mayor Scott Robertson as defendants and attorney Mark Meyerhoff is listed as the defendants’ representation in the case.
Santillan’s complaint against the city of Selma, which was most recently amended on Oct. 9 of this year, includes claims of retaliation, breach of an employment contract and settlement agreement, wrongful termination, intentional infliction of emotional distress, racial discrimination, sexual harassment, abusive conduct and more.
It outlines the events leading up to Santillan’s termination, particularly the conflict between Santillan and council members related to the council’s reorganization following the November 2024 election. The case seeks relief for a variety of damages, including lost past and future wages, and requests a jury trial.
The city of Selma then filed a lawsuit against Santillan on Oct. 28, 2025, with the complaint for declaratory relief. Costanzo is representing the city in this case.
As background information, the city’s lawsuit lists Santillan’s employment history with Selma and amendments made to his contract. It highlights the disagreement between council members in approving Santillan’s contract amendments, as well as Santillan’s pay increases and a provision in his contract requiring a four-fifths council vote for termination.
The city’s case also references the 2024 settlement agreement between Santillan and the city in which the city paid Santillan $350,000 and added a five-year extension to his employment contract.
The cause of action in the case reiterates the same points used to terminate Santillan’s employment. This included claims that Santillan’s employment agreement and settlement were made in violation of the government code.
The case seeks a declaratory judgment — defined by the United States Courts as a “legal determination of a court defining the rights and obligations of litigants to resolve legal uncertainty” — related to the city’s argument that Santillan violated the government code. It also asks the court to award the city all compensation paid by the city to Santillan under his contract and settlement.
Court decision
An anti-SLAPP motion refers to Strategic Litigation Against Public Participation. According to the ruling, it “provides a procedural remedy to dismiss nonmeritorious litigation brought ‘primarily to chill the valid exercise of constitutional rights of freedom of speech and petition for redress of grievances,’” as defined under state statute.
The ruling’s explanation states that California’s anti-SLAPP statute can be invoked to challenge four different categories of speech and the California Supreme Court has established a two-step process to litigate an anti-SLAPP motion.
Through this process, the court found that Santillan met the burden required to show that the complaint filed by the city “arises from protected activity,” meaning Santillan’s actions listed in the city’s complaint were protected under the right to free speech. The court also found that Selma could not demonstrate a likelihood of prevailing on its claims for declaratory relief.
According to the ruling explanation, declaratory relief cannot correct past wrongs and instead must address future rights; however, the city’s complaint for declaratory relief solely addresses prior actions.
Although the ruling granted the anti-SLAPP motion and struck the city’s complaint for declaratory relief, it did so “without prejudice to Selma asserting its claims” in Santillan’s case against the city. This means that Selma can still use its claims from the complaint in its defense against Santillan’s various complaints.
The judgment also allows Santillan to bring a motion for recovery of attorney fees to the court for consideration.


